Request A Quote

Posted By

on 13 October 2015

City of Cleveland to hire armed security guards to patrol West Side Market parking lots

Story image for security guards from hours ago

The city of Cleveland soon will hire armed security guards to patrol the parking lots behind the historic West Side Market. (Marvin Fong, The …

The city of Cleveland soon will hire armed security guards to patrol the parking lots behind the historic West Side Market. (Marvin Fong, The Plain Dealer)


By Leila Atassi, Northeast Ohio Media GroupThe Plain Dealer
Email the author | Follow on Twitter
on October 12, 2015 at 7:33 PM, updated October 12, 2015 at 7:52 Pm

CLEVELAND, Ohio — The parking lots behind Cleveland’s historic West Side Market soon will be protected by armed security guards during business hours.

Cleveland City Council on Monday passed legislation authorizing the city to spend $86,000 a year on what city officials said will likely be off-duty Cleveland police officers, replacing a contract with Willo Security for unarmed guards.

Susie Claytor, the deputy commissioner who oversees the Public Auditorium and West Side Market, told members of council during a Finance Committee meeting Monday that the new contract will cost more than the current one, given that police officers have more training and arrest powers. But she could not recall how much the current contract was worth.

Council members pressed Claytor to explain why daytime security guards at the lot should be armed. They wondered if there had been an uptick in crime in the area, necessitating armed security.

Claytor said she believes the administration is merely trying to take preventive measures, and that the new contract is just one step in the process of assuming control of the lots from the West Side Markets Tenants Association, whose lease on the lots expired last year.

Councilman Joe Cimperman, who represents the Market District, said he welcomes the legislation and looks forward to other ordinances, which, he said, will be aimed at improving parking overall in the booming neighborhood.

Cimperman said the city is considering six different options for structuring parking fees at the lot. He foreshadowed legislation that will propose up to two hours of free parking and a charge of up to $2 for every hour after that.

He said the fees will encourage turnover and deter RTA riders or attendees of downtown sporting events from leaving their cars in the lot for prolonged periods, limiting available spots for market patrons.

Without a remedy to the neighborhood’s dearth of parking spaces, Cimperman said, market customers who can’t find parking go elsewhere. He acknowledged, however, the pushback from some market vendors, who want the parking problem solved but oppose charging their customers to park.

“It’s going to get more intense before it gets less intense,” Cimperman said of the debate. “The reason is that I want this market to be open when our grandkids are alive. … We own this asset. Let’s lead.”

Councilman Michael Polensek, who voted against hiring armed security guards, expressed concern that the city might charge the market tenants more in rent to cover the increased cost.

“I just want to make sure that in 2015 we don’t screw something up that has been there for 100 years,” Polensek said. “I want to make sure that, in the true sense of America, these small business people are protected.”

Claytor said that next year’s leases have not been finalized, and that she is unaware of how the cost of armed security would effect those agreements. But she added that the parking fees that eventually will be collected will help fund the lots’ maintenance and other expenses at the city-owned market.

Cimperman added that the expense for armed guards would be in keeping with what market vendors used to pay to cover maintenance under their old lease on the lots.

Tommy Boutros, president of the tenants association, could not be reached for comment Monday.